
We’re spending Thanksgiving with my husband’s Aunt Helen and Uncle Ed and their family. It will be exciting, because Erik’s cousin Walter and his wife Margaret are expecting their first baby, the first child of the next generation. When I say expecting, I mean expecting to have it any minute, maybe even today! It’s a boy and they’ve decided to name him Henry and I love that name and I’m glad that they aren’t keeping it all a big secret.

Thanksgiving is the only meal of the year where I want pure tradition, the nostalgia of Grandma’s stuffing (yes, cooked inside the bird, I’ve never seen anyone get sick from this, have you?) and the sweet potatoes with the marshmallows and cranberry sauce not from a can and lots and lots of gravy. But this year, I’ve been directed to make an apple pie, and only an apple pie. That means I’ve got to put all of the meaning of Thanksgiving into this one dish. All of my nostalgia and wishing to be with my family and my memory of all the Thanksgiving meals I’ve ever made and ever eaten and also that vision of the ideal Thanksgiving and the ideal apple pie. Whoa, I’ll stop right there and come back to earth (and forget about the time that we caught my brother Paul on fire). It’s just a pie and I should just try and make a good one.
I’m using a standard pie crust and I have decided to go along with Melissa Clark whose New York Times article last week suggested that a 70/30 combination of butter and lard would yield a perfect flavor to flakiness ratio. What to put inside of the pie is the big question. I’d love to be like the people in Cook’s Illustrated and embark on a quest for my version of the perfect apple pie filling, but I’ve only got about two hours to put this together and get myself washed, primped and dressed in an outfit that is the perfect ratio of casual and chic, maybe I’ll follow the 70/30 Clark formula in this arena as well.
As is often my first impulse, I turn to history, books and the internet to find out what I should be doing with my food. The Forme of Cury, an English cookbook from around 1390 has what I think is the first written recipe for apple pie in English. “For to make Tartys in Applis” doesn’t mention sugar, though it includes figs and raisins. The only spice it calls for is saffron. I am intrigued by the idea of the bright yellow color this would give, but I’m not sure that my husband’s family would like it, so I’ll stick to the usual cinnamon and brown sugar and maybe a little lemon juice to perk it up. www.epicurious.com lists 112 recipes for apple pie, but I don’t have any apple juice and I’m opposed to putting molasses in my filling and I don’t want any sort of streusel topping or nuts or other ingredients fooling around with my apples while they are cooking inside of their crust. Vanilla extract? That’s one of the ingredients listed for “Classic Double-Crust Apple Pie”, which sums up, I think, what I am looking to make, but without the vanilla extract. I think that for sources, I’ll just use what I remember from Grandma, my mother and my brother Paul. Peel and core the apples, then root around in the cupboard to make sure I have cinnamon and brown sugar. I think there’s a lemon in the refrigerator. If there is, I’ll put in a little lemon juice. But not any zest as the Joy of Cooking recipe suggests. As far as I’m concerned, the only really big question is the thickener. Flour or corn starch? Tapioca has no place with apples in my mind, though I’d use it with berries or peaches. I like the suggestion of using a little of both, because I like the way corn starch makes the filling taste in your mouth, but I don’t like the gel-like consistency or the clear looking appearance. It’s too much like the stuff that comes out of the can. Maybe I should just go with all flour? I’ve got to get over this test kitchen lust. I’ll just write it down as I go along, bake the thing and take some pictures.

The crust
- 2 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
- 1/2 tsp. salt
- 14 Tbs. butter, chilled, cut into 1/2 inch pieces
- 8 Tbs. lard, chilled, cut into 1/2 inch pieces
- 1/4 cup ice water (or more if needed)
Place flour and salt in a food processor and pulse briefly. Add butter and lard and pulse again until mixture forms pea-size bits. Add water a little at a time and pulse until the whole thing comes together in a mass. Divide dough in half and form two disks, wrap with plastic and refrigerate for at least one hour and up to 3 days before rolling out.

The filling
- 9-10 apples, I suggest a mixture of 3 different varieties, I used Cortland, Granny Smith and Gala
- 1/4 cup brown sugar
- 1 lemon, juiced
- 2 Tbs. flour
- 2 Tbs. corn starch
- 1/2 tsp. cinnamon (or more to taste)
- 1 pinch salt
Mix ingredients together in a large bowl, taste for flavoring. You may decide you need more sugar or more flour, depending on your apples.
Assembly and baking

Preheat oven to 450 degrees. Butter a 9 inch glass pie dish. Roll out bottom crust and place in pie dish. Place in freezer for ten minutes. Roll out top crust. Place apple mixture on top of bottom crust and top with top crust. Cut off excess dough and crimp edges. Optional: wash top of pie with egg yolk mixed with milk and sprinkle with sugar. Slash top of pie in several places in order to allow steam to escape. Bake at 450 degrees for 10 minutes, then reduce temperature to 350 degrees. Bake for another 45 minutes to 1 hour until pie is golden on top.












Comments